October 2026 review · same 50 texts
Grubby vs Ryne
Grubby led on 5 detectors, Ryne on 0, tied on 1 detector
In the October 2026 HumanizerEval review, Grubby and Ryne rewrote the same 50 English texts. Grubby cleared all 6 detectors on 0 of them; Ryne on 0. The difference is mostly Originality.ai Turbo: on 50 samples Grubby passed it where Ryne failed, and the reverse never happened. On Originality.ai 5.0 the two were close to even.
Per-sample agreement
| Detector | Passed more often | Margin | Both passed | Neither passed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pangram 4.1 | Grubby | 5 to 0 | 0 | 45 |
| GPTZero 2026-10-07-base | Grubby | 34 to 0 | 0 | 16 |
| Originality.ai Turbo | Grubby | 50 to 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Originality.ai 5.0 model-5.0 | Tied | 0 to 0 | 0 | 50 |
| ZeroGPT default | Grubby | 46 to 0 | 2 | 2 |
| Winston AI 5.0 | Grubby | 50 to 0 | 0 | 0 |
| All 6 detectors | Tied | 0 to 0 | 0 | 50 |
Every count is computed from scores.csv at build time, not transcribed. “Neither passed” counts the texts that defeated both tools; on Pangram that was 45 of 50 here.
Quality and output discipline
| Measure | Grubby | Ryne |
|---|---|---|
| 76% | 64% | |
| 64% | 92% | |
| 100% | 100% | |
| 78% | 94% | |
| 1.19 | 1.02 | |
| 1 | 0 | |
| 0 | 0 | |
| Academic | Aggressive, beast mode | |
| Website | grubby.ai | ryne.ai |
On per-sample quality scores, Grubby scored higher on 12 samples, Ryne on 20, and the two tied on 18. Ryne’s output was shorter on 49 of 50 samples; mean length ratios were 1.19 and 1.02, or 19% longer than the input and 2% longer than the input respectively.
Where each one outperforms the other
Grubby
- Pangram: passed 5 of 50 against 0, including 5 samples where Ryne failed, against 0 the other way.
- GPTZero: passed 34 of 50 against 0, including 34 samples where Ryne failed, against 0 the other way.
- Originality.ai Turbo: passed 50 of 50 against 0, including 50 samples where Ryne failed, against 0 the other way.
- Originality.ai 5.0: tied at 0 of 50 but on a higher mean human score, 9.8% to 4.2%. It passed 0 samples where Ryne failed.
- ZeroGPT: passed 48 of 50 against 2, including 46 samples where Ryne failed, against 0 the other way.
- Winston AI: passed 50 of 50 against 0, including 50 samples where Ryne failed, against 0 the other way.
- Factual consistency: 76% against 64%.
Ryne
- Naturalness: 92% against 64%.
- Stance preservation: 94% against 78%.
- Length: shorter output on 49 of 50 samples, which matters under a word limit.
Grubby vs Ryne FAQ
Is Grubby better than Ryne?
In the October 2026 HumanizerEval review, Grubby cleared all 6 detectors on 0 of the 50 shared samples and Ryne on 0. On Originality.ai 5.0 the two were within 6 points of each other. Quality ran 12 samples to 20, with 18 ties.
Which humanizer is best for Pangram, Grubby or Ryne?
Grubby. In October 2026, Grubby passed Pangram on 5 of the 50 shared samples and Ryne on 0. On 5 samples Grubby passed where Ryne failed; the reverse never happened. Both failed on 45.
Which humanizer changes the text less?
Ryne. It scored higher on per-sample quality on 20 of 50 samples, against 12. Grubby’s outputs averaged 1.19× the input length and passed factual consistency on 76%; Ryne’s averaged 1.02× and passed on 64%. On stance preservation the split was 78% to 94%. Ryne produced the shorter output on 49 of 50 samples.
More comparisons
- StealthGPT vs Grubby
- StealthGPT vs Ryne
- Undetectable.ai vs Grubby
- Undetectable.ai vs Ryne
- WriteHuman vs Grubby
- WriteHuman vs Ryne
- Rephrasy vs Grubby
- Rephrasy vs Ryne
- Grubby vs RewriteAI
- Grubby vs Phrasly
- Grubby vs HIX Bypass
- Grubby vs Humbot
- Grubby vs BypassGPT
- RewriteAI vs Ryne
- Phrasly vs Ryne
- HIX Bypass vs Ryne
- Humbot vs Ryne
- BypassGPT vs Ryne
- Full October 2026 leaderboard: all 11 tools, 80.3% down to 0.7%